Saturday, September 05, 2009

The Autoimmune Epidemic


Journalist and advocate Donna Jackson Nakazawa wrote The Autoimmune Epidemic after she experienced two bouts of Guillain-Barre syndrome, a severe autoimmune disease. She discusses statistics, possible causes, and the medical research into autoimmune diseases. I had an interest in the topic and this is the only one my library had. Unfortunately, I didn't think the book lived up to its potential.

The book is heavily researched, judging by the notes section in the back. Unfortunately, reading the book is like watching an expose on Dateline. The author lumps every possible environmental cause, suspect chemical, and lifestyle into one big soup to make it appear that autoimmune diseases are a plague on society. Reading between the lines, I have no doubt that there are connections between an environmental toxic overload, genetic pre-disposition and lifestyle that contribute to the likelihood of developing one of these diseases. I think she speaks some truth. But it was hard to read between the hyperbole and statistical spinning to decipher the actual medical history and research on the diseases. I was more interested in how scientists and doctors learned to recognize the problem and treat it. Instead she glosses over it and delves into politics - the usual mantra of not enough government funded research, autoimmune clusters, and environmental regulations. I think the book lost complete credibility when she pulled out Al Gore and his scientifically poor documentary as proof of the spread of autoimmune diseases.

As far as this kind of book goes, probably worth skipping.

Thursday, September 03, 2009

Anne's House of Dreams


I haven't read any of the Anne of Green Gables books in a long time. I recently re-watched all of the Kevin Sullivan film versions except for the latest incarnation starring Barbara Hershey. I was perplexed why Kevin Sullivan wrote an entirely new story for the third film, Anne - The Continuing Story. While the movie was ok, it was a huge departure from the original source material. Some might even say Kevin Sullivan went too far.

So I went back to the books. L. M. Montgomery, if I remember right, really didn't want to write anymore Anne books by the time she got to the last three in the series, but she did anyway for the pay check. Those who are more up on their Anne history, pipe in here. Anyway, some say the quality of the stories was lacking. I tend to disagree, especially with Anne's House of Dreams. If you compare the mood of this book versus the last movie, you will find the book fits right into the Anne universe whereas the movie does not.

In this story Anne and Gilbert are married and they set off to another location on the island, Four Winds,where Gilbert is to take over his uncle's medical practice. They rent a cottage with views of the ocean and meet interesting people while they set out to live their dreams. There is the salty Captain Jack, the sad neighbor Leslie Moore, and the spinster Miss Cornelia. Anne has the unique position to befriend them all and bring some measure of happiness to Four Winds. Anne also has to learn how to deal with the realities of life and not just her dreams. The story is touching and a welcome addition to the series.

I think there was enough fodder for Sullivan to create a screenplay on just this book alone. I am still puzzled why he didn't. Could he not secure the rights? Did he not want to recast Marilla? Was he bored by the material? In any event, read the books - they are enjoyable.